5. Strategies
Win Rate vs ROI: Why a High Strike Rate Can Still Lose You Money
Published: 2026-11-15
Ask most punters how good a tipster is and they'll quote the strike rate: "He hits 40% winners." It sounds impressive. But strike rate on its own tells you almost nothing about whether you'll make money.
What is win rate?
Win rate (or strike rate) is simply the percentage of bets that win. Ten bets, four winners, that's a 40% win rate.
What is ROI?
ROI (return on investment) measures profit against the money you put in. If you stake 00 in total and get back 12, your profit is 2 and your ROI is +12%. If you get back $88, your ROI is -12%.
Two punters, one surprise
Punter A: the favourite backer
Punter A bets on 100 short-priced horses at an average of $2.20. He hits 40 winners, a strong 40% strike rate.
- Staked: 00
- Returned: 40 x $2.20 = $88
- Result: -2 (ROI -12%)
Punter B: the value hunter
Punter B bets on 100 horses at an average of $6.00. She hits only 20 winners, half of Punter A's strike rate.
- Staked: 00
- Returned: 20 x $6.00 = 20
- Result: +$20 (ROI +20%)
Punter A wins twice as often and still loses. Punter B loses four bets out of five and still comes out ahead. The difference is the price.
The break-even rule
For any average price, there's a strike rate you need just to break even. Divide 100 by the odds:
- At $2.00 you need to win 50% of bets to break even
- At $3.00 you need 33.3%
- At $5.00 you need 20%
- At 0.00 you need 10%
Win more often than that at those prices and you profit. Win less and you lose, no matter how good the strike rate looks.
What to look for in any tipping service
- ROI over a long period, not just strike rate
- Every bet published, losers included, so the ROI can't be cherry-picked
- Real prices that you could actually have got at the time
That's why IdealBet publishes winners and losers alike in the historical performance grid: so you can check the ROI for yourself, not just the strike rate.
Past results don't guarantee future results. Please gamble responsibly. Gambling Help: 1800 858 858.